Is the AI trade over?

After a sharp drawdown in some AI chip stocks are we ready to push the SELL button?

Tushar Pradhan

11/16/20263 min read

two hands touching each other in front of a pink background
two hands touching each other in front of a pink background

Is the AI trade history?

Recent events are pointing to a possible reevaluation of AI companies and their fundamentals. While human behavior is what it is, the concern is not around the leadership issue. The concern is about the tendency of investors to overlook detail when it comes to either a visionary founder or the wave of popularity a certain theme brings. At this point of time, certain issues that were highlighted as concerning, among AI companies, were pushed in the background since the noise around growth and the sheer outperformance in the stock markets was loud enough to drown out the concerns. However, with a major event related change in the status quo, investors are bringing the risks to the forefront and in the limelight

What are the known risks in AI

  • An alarming amount of debt raised by leading hyperscalers funding massive capital expenditure on AI related infrastructure. Often the capex has come at lower interest rates than the rates currently.

  • Juxtaposed with a possibility of rising rates, this can jeopardize smooth repricing of this debt. Companies unable to turn cash positive before the interest costs start to hurt can see themselves facing an uncomfortable situation Also, raising fresh capital when they most need it may become a real issue in the coming quarters

  • AI adaption is still not a given. As errors and applicability issues rise among early adaptors, a sense of caution has emerged ensuring a slower, more measured rate of adoption of AI tools for enterprise applications at least. Generative and Agentic AI is showing significant growth, but this is not as lucrative from a ROI perspective to hyperscalers as much as enterprise adaption.

  • Significant cross-investments across chip manufacturers, AI hyperscalers, AI adaptors, AI start-up companies engaged in delivery of AI solutions, either in the hardware or software domains – could lead to a valuation bubble, that is at risk of collapse if the dominos do fall. The contagion could spread as in earlier crashes to mainstream companies via banks, funders and hedge funds that could see a second-degree impact.

Do the unknown unknowns far outweigh the know unknows?

What remains unknown currently is the full impact of AI on the global economy, the rise in productivity as a result, if any, and the collateral damage it causes on employment, social and business disruption. Traditional business models are being evaluated for a post AI world and there could be much more in store that we cannot see as of now.

Different economies and business models will be impacted differently and the scale at which this will hit is also yet a big unknown. Media businesses, the rise in alternative new media, communications and information technology sectors are at the frontline of this change as we see it now. However, the next line of defense is yet unknown.

What we also do not know as of now is how all of this will change education, the whole concept of learning, and the whole knowledge economy – now that mere knowledge will be available to all without the prerequisite of degree or some third-party validation of credentials. This is a significant unknown

Given the above scenario investors are naturally wary and are looking to reduce the exposure to the AI trade or at least look to ways to reduce the concentration in the bet. Could India be an allocative preference for global asset allocators?

Is India the alternative to the AI trade?

For foreign investors India remains a difficult market to deploy significant capital quickly

  • As a portion of global asset allocation by institutional investors India remains a significant underweight. So, any significant move is not immediate

  • With increasing clarity on the AI situation, this could be a quick reversal creating much volatility in the interim

  • Global flows are increasingly funded by retail US investors who have the highest amount of savings in equity markets in its history. Such large retail flows do not have the ability to look at India as a diversifier. Hence this group is unlikely to choose this asset class

  • At best this could be a tactical institutional play – Investors should stay wary of such inflows as they could reverse very quickly

Earnings growth and economic expansion remain long term drivers of investor interest

While different markets remain popular among global investors for various reasons, the India growth story is unique among them all and a sustained investment over a period is likely to yield handsome dividends.

The case for India is unique. A standalone growth story for the next decade at the junction of long-term positive trends of demographics, GDP growth, domestic infrastructure and capital investment and relatively benign interest rates. Inflation and currency will remain volatile throughout this period. Domestic investors need not worry about currency, and if the inflation picture remains within the RBI range, this too should not impact domestic investors too much

The reason to invest in Indian equities remains its domestic growth story and that should remain the focus at this time

Happy investing!